Category pages tell Google the homepage is the “real” page
All 8 category pages in the sample carry two canonical tags. The first names the page itself; the second — which Google may treat as the deciding one — names the homepage. The sitemap lists 6 more categories and 28 paginated category URLs on the same template; we did not fetch those, so check them after the fix instead of assuming.
Evidence
/collections/womens-running
<link rel="canonical" href="https://northwind-shoes.example/collections/womens-running">
<link rel="canonical" href="https://northwind-shoes.example/"> ← added by the SEO app
- Why it matters
- A canonical tag says “this is the main version of the page”. When a category names the homepage instead, Google can drop the category from results and show the homepage — or nothing — for searches like “women’s trail running shoes”. Categories are usually a store’s best landing pages for shopping searches.
- Cause
- The SEO app’s “Canonical URL” setting is “Site root” for all pages, and the theme also prints its own correct canonical, so every category ends up with two conflicting tags.
- How to fix
In an app or pluginNeeds a developer
- In the SEO app’s settings, switch “Canonical URL” to “Page URL” — or turn its canonical output off and keep the theme’s tag.
- Once the fix is live, request indexing for the main categories in Google Search Console (URL Inspection → Request indexing).
For the developer
- Make sure layout/theme.liquid prints exactly one canonical tag from Shopify’s canonical_url, and that no app snippet adds a second one.
- Check a paginated category (?page=2): its canonical is its own URL, not page 1.
<link rel="canonical" href="{{ canonical_url }}">Official guide: Shopify: SEO metadata in themes (canonical_url)
- Who · effort
- Store admin (setting) + developer (theme check) · Low effort, 1–2 hours
- How to verify
- Open a category, press Ctrl+U and search for rel="canonical": exactly one result, with the page’s own URL. In Search Console → URL Inspection, “User-declared canonical” equals the inspected URL.
Show Hide 8 affected sampled category pages
- /collections/womens-running
- /collections/mens-running
- /collections/trail-running
- /collections/walking-shoes
- /collections/wide-fit
- /collections/boots
- /collections/sale
- /collections/new-arrivals
- Same template, not fetched: 6 more categories and 28 paginated URLs listed in the sitemap